Built to Learn: What the Circle of Protection Will Tell Us

A group of young volunteers outside a building, framed by a white Nigerian pattern ring
A man speaks to a class, framed by a white ring of leaf motifs

Test and learn · Afghanistan · Nigeria · Pakistan

An always-on campaign is a new way of working for the polio programme, so UNICEF’s Digital Community Engagement (DCE) team built it to learn as it runs.

Author & editorDaria Shubina · Knowledge Management Specialist, UNICEF Digital Community Engagement (DCE)

Digital campaigns for polio have always produced numbers such as impressions, views and reach. They have rarely shown which message actually moves a parent to vaccinate. The always-on Circle of Protection campaigns that DCE is launching in Afghanistan, Nigeria and Pakistan are designed to answer that, because each launch doubles as a live learning cycle.

Four questions, asked the same way everywhere

Each country’s Phase 1 tests the same four questions: whether shorter or longer films perform better; whether a heightened sense of jeopardy increases engagement or switches people off; whether pride resonates most at the level of the family, the community or the country; and which practical motivations move people most, from ease of access and a better future to risk and completing all doses. Because the questions are identical, results can be compared across three very different contexts.

A family of eleven films

Each country runs a family of eleven films in its own languages (Dari and Pashto in Afghanistan, Urdu and Pashto in Pakistan, English and Hausa in Nigeria), plus static images: a hero film in four versions, three “finish line” films that pair a sense that eradication is close with a reminder of risk, and four short motivation films, each built around a single driver: vaccination is free, fast and close to home; a better tomorrow; the risk of paralysis; and the need for multiple doses. Every variant differs from its neighbour in one element, so the results can be read cleanly.

Three Afghan Circle of Protection campaign images with children framed by rings of local symbols

Phase 1 campaign images from Afghanistan. Circle of Protection campaign materials, 2026. © UNICEF

Two measures of success

The films are judged on two measures. The first is whether people watch: views, completion and engagement, tracked on a real-time analytics dashboard shared with country offices. The second is whether perceptions shift. About every two weeks, a short survey opens inside Facebook or Instagram, so people answer without leaving the app. It goes to people the campaign has reached and to a similar audience it has not, and the difference between the two groups shows the campaign’s effect on intent to vaccinate and on safety concerns. Reach is treated as a means, and progress is judged by dialogue, learning and changes in vaccination intent. Because the campaign stays on, the audiences it builds are kept, then retargeted and deepened in the next phase.

11

films per country in Phase 1

4

questions tested the same way in every country

~2 weeks

between short perception surveys inside Facebook and Instagram

What Phase 2 does with the answers

Phase 2, planned for October, carries the best-performing routes forward and moves the creative to specific audiences and messages. Broad emotional storytelling gives way to 15-second films written for mothers, fathers, grandparents, community leaders and young people, each addressing that audience’s own barriers. In Nigeria, delivery narrows to fifteen priority states in the north where risk is concentrated. The call to action changes as well: instead of a landing page, people are invited to tap through to WhatsApp, where UNICEF’s information lines, built on RapidPro, answer their questions one to one. The conversation also asks whether people plan to vaccinate, which gives a clearer measure of the campaign’s effect. The films are assembled with dynamic creative optimisation, so versions can be tested against each other quickly.

Diagram of Phase 2 audiences: carers (mothers, fathers, grandparents), leaders (community and religious leaders) and engaged youth

Phase 2 moves from broad targeting to specific audiences. Circle of Protection campaign materials, 2026. © UNICEF

Three campaign photos framed by localised rings: a father hugging his son, a grandfather with two grandchildren, and two young men talking

Fathers, grandparents and young people: some of the audiences Phase 2 speaks to. Circle of Protection campaign image, 2026. © UNICEF

Table of three behaviours the platform aims to drive: engage, vaccinate children, advocate, with the audience for each

The three behaviours the platform is designed to drive. Circle of Protection campaign materials, 2026. © UNICEF

Why it matters

Continuity is what makes learning compound. In a burst campaign, an insight arrives after the money is spent. In an always-on system, it arrives while there is still time to act on it, and it stays in the system for the next country and the next round.

Afghanistan, Nigeria and Pakistan — September 2026.